Chapter 9 of 10

Spreads, commissions, swaps and slippage

Every cost that sits between your idea and your P&L, and how to keep them small.

Every trade has a cost before the market moves a single pip. Costs are small per trade, but they come out of every trade, win or lose, and they add up to one of the biggest differences between traders who make money and traders who almost do.

The spread

You buy at the higher ask price and sell at the lower bid price. The gap is the spread, and you pay it as soon as you open a trade: a new position always starts slightly negative. Spreads are tightest on the busiest instruments during the busiest sessions and widen during quiet hours, around the daily rollover and during major news.

SELL at the bid1.08520BUY at the ask1.08528Spread: 0.8 pipsEvery new trade starts this far in the red
On a typical EUR/USD quote, buying and immediately selling would lose the 0.8-pip spread.

Commission

Some accounts charge only through the spread. Others, often called raw or ECN accounts, offer very tight spreads plus a fixed commission per lot. Futures always charge commission per contract, plus exchange and clearing fees. Compare the total cost, not just the headline spread.

Worked example: one round trip

1 standard lot of EUR/USD on a raw account.

Spread 0.2 pips × $10 = $2. Commission $3.50 per side × 2 = $7.

Total = $9 per round trip, the same as a 0.9-pip spread on a commission-free account. Neither is automatically cheaper; you have to add it up.

Swap (overnight financing)

Hold a forex or CFD position past the daily rollover (usually 5 p.m. New York time) and you pay or receive a swap. It is based on the interest-rate difference between the two currencies, plus the broker's markup. If you buy a currency with a higher interest rate than the one you sell, you may earn a small credit. In most cases, after markup, you pay.

In forex, Wednesday night's swap is usually charged three times, because spot trades settle two business days later and that rollover covers the weekend.

Mon× 1Tue× 1Wed× 3Thu× 1Fri× 1Nights a swap is charged in forex (Wednesday covers the weekend)
Check your broker's swap rates before holding trades for days or weeks. On some instruments they cost more than the spread.

Slippage

Slippage is the difference between the price you expected and the price you got, as you saw in chapter 8. It can be negative or, less often, positive. It is largest on market and stop orders in fast markets and thin hours.

Why costs matter more on shorter timeframes

Costs are roughly fixed per trade, but targets shrink with your timeframe. The same 1.5-pip round-trip cost is a small fee for a swing trader and a huge tax on a scalper.

Scalp5-pip target30% of target goes to costsDay trade25-pip target6% of target goes to costsSwing120-pip target1.25% of target goes to costs
The same 1.5-pip round-trip cost against three different targets.
CostWhen you pay itHow to reduce it
SpreadEvery trade, on entryTrade liquid instruments in busy sessions
CommissionEvery trade, per lot or contractCompare total cost per round trip
Swap / financingEach night a position is heldCheck rates; avoid holding through Wednesday if costly
SlippageMarket and stop orders in fast movesAvoid big news; use limits where you can

Key takeaways

  • You buy at the ask and sell at the bid; the spread is paid on every trade.
  • Compare total cost per round trip: spread plus commission, not either on its own.
  • Swaps are charged on positions held overnight, usually triple on Wednesday in forex.
  • Shorter-term trading is far more sensitive to costs, because the targets are smaller.